Staten Island is home to 133 pizza restaurants featured in the Northeast Pizza Guide, spanning styles including Coal-Fired, Deep Dish, Neapolitan, New York Style. Browse the full list below to explore what Staten Island, New York has to offer.
All Pizza Restaurants in Staten Island
A & S Pizza is a pizzeria located at 87 Stuyvesant Place in Staten Island, NY. The restaurant offers free delivery and serves a variety of pizza styles inclu…
Amalfi Coast Pizzeria & Restaurant is located at 572 Midland Ave in Staten Island, NY. The restaurant offers a menu featuring various pizza styles, pasta din…
Ambrosino's serves delicious antipasti, wraps, salads, sides, soups, pizza, pie, pasta, heros, entrees and more. Located at 240 Arden Ave in Staten Island, N…
Ambrosino's Pizza & Restaurant is a Staten Island pizzeria with two locations in Oakwood and Arden Heights. They serve pizza, specialty pies, pasta, heroes, …
In Staten Island, Amici Brick Oven Pizza serves pizza from its location on Amboy Road. The restaurant uses a brick oven to prepare its pies, offering a tradi…
Visit website →
Baci is an Italian restaurant located on Richmond Road in Staten Island that serves authentic Italian cuisine with modern twists. They offer generous portion…
Bari's Pizza offers meals of excellent quality including Pizza, Pasta, and Sandwiches. They provide both takeout and food delivery services in Staten Island,…
Big Al's is a family-owned and operated pizzeria located in the Great Kills neighborhood of Staten Island at 4069 Hylan Boulevard. They have been serving the…
A pizza and sports bar located on New Dorp Lane in Staten Island, this establishment serves pizza alongside a full sports bar experience. The New Dorp Lane l…
Visit website →
Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is a pizzeria located at 1250 Hylan Boulevard in Staten Island, a major thoroughfare running through the heart of the neighborhood. T…
Visit website →
Brother's Pizzeria is located at 750 Port Richmond Ave in Staten Island, NY. The restaurant serves pizzas, sandwiches, salads, calzones, and more. Delivery t…
In Staten Island, Cafe Luna serves pizza at 1300 Hylan Boulevard, a location easily accessible to locals and visitors navigating the neighborhood. The restau…
Visit website →
Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant opened on Staten Island in 1993 and is owned by John Lucchese and Eric Stropoli. The restaurant offers takeout, delivery,…
Campania Coal-Fired Pizza operates from 240 Page Ave in Staten Island, serving coal-fired pizza to the local community. The restaurant's location on Page Ave…
Visit website →
Campania Coal-Fired Pizza operates at 1801 Hylan Blvd in Staten Island, offering coal-fired pizza to the Hylan Boulevard area. The restaurant serves diners s…
Visit website →
Campania Coal-Fired Pizza operates in Staten Island at 3900 Richmond Ave, serving coal-fired pizza to the local community. The restaurant handles both dine-i…
Visit website →
Casa Ninos Pizza Bar serves artisanal, scratch-made wood-fired pizza and traditional Italian cuisine on Staten Island's South Shore. They craft hand-tossed c…
Chuck E. Cheese Staten Island is an entertainment venue offering arcade games, pizza, and birthday parties. The location features gameplay, food, drinks, des…
Visit website →
Ciro Pizza Cafe was established in 1997 by Ciro Pappalardo and John Piscopo. Ciro immigrated from Naples, Italy in 1962 and worked in the restaurant business…
Visit website →
Crispy Pizza serves delicious pizza at Richmond Terrace, Staten Island. They use only the finest ingredients and everything is prepared fresh daily.
DOUGH by Licastri Silver Lake offers traditional pizza, specialty pies, and Italian food established in 2016. The restaurant uses an almost 100 year old fami…
Dairy Palace is a kosher pizza, dairy, and vegetarian restaurant located at 2216 Victory Blvd in Staten Island. It has been a landmark since 1986 and is stri…
Dario The Baker Pizzeria operates at 4392 Victory Boulevard in Staten Island, New York. The restaurant serves pizza to the Victory Boulevard area and surroun…
Visit website →
In Staten Island, Denino's Pizzeria & Tavern serves New York style pizza at 524 Port Richmond Ave. Stop by this Port Richmond neighborhood spot for thin-crus…
Visit website →
Di Farina Pizzeria serves pizza to the Staten Island community from its Forest Avenue location. The restaurant offers dine-in and takeout service for those s…
Visit website →
DiLeo's Pizzeria is located in Staten Island, NY and has established a reputation for providing high quality food, excellent customer service, and speedy del…
Domenico's Pizza & Pasta is a pizzeria located on Amboy Road in Staten Island, serving the area with pizza and pasta dishes. The restaurant sits along a majo…
Visit website →
Domenico's Pizzeria and Ristorante Antico is a local Staten Island Italian eatery offering fresh Italian pizzas, pastas, entrees, heros, and wraps. Their men…
Visit website →
This location offers pizza delivery and carryout along with pasta, wings, and more. The menu includes specialty pizzas, breads, chicken, desserts, oven-baked…
Domino's Pizza on Amboy Road serves up pizza for diners across Staten Island looking for a quick meal or takeout order. Located at 6410 Amboy Rd, this spot m…
Domino's Pizza operates at 1785 Victory Boulevard in Staten Island, serving pizza and related items to the Victory Boulevard area. The location functions as …
Pizza enthusiasts on Staten Island will find Domino's Pizza at 1430 Richmond Ave, ready to deliver hot pies straight to your door or available for pickup. Th…
Domino's offers pizza delivery and carryout along with pasta, wings, and more. The menu includes specialty pizzas, breads, chicken, desserts, oven-baked past…
EatItalian NYC is located at 655 Rossville Ave in Staten Island, New York. This Italian pizza restaurant serves the Rossville Avenue area, offering dine-in a…
Visit website →
El Paso Pizzeria & Deli is located at 358 Targee St in the Fox Hills section of Staten Island, New York. The restaurant is known for mouthwatering pizzas and…
Frank & Danny's serves pizza, pasta, soup, and salads made with fresh ingredients. The restaurant is located at 4369 Amboy Road, Staten Island, NY 10312 and …
Frank's Bay Pizza is a pizza restaurant located at 117 Broad St in Staten Island, NY. The menu features various pizza styles including Sicilian, Grandma's, a…
Georgie's Pizzeria sits on Targee Street in Staten Island, serving pizza to neighbors and visitors alike. Located at 360 Targee St, this spot draws people in…
Visit website →
Gino's Pizzeria is located in the Port Richmond neighborhood of Staten Island at 1351 Forest Avenue. It is a pizzeria restaurant that welcomes customers dail…
Visit website →
Villa Monte Pizzeria & Restaurant has been an Italian food establishment for more than 30 years, operated by Chef-owner Augusto 'Augie' Mandara and his broth…
Goodfella's is a brick oven pizza restaurant established in 1992 at 1718 Hylan Blvd in Staten Island, NY. They serve award-winning Italian food including piz…
Il Forno Pizzeria is located at 6382 Amboy Rd in Pleasant Plains and serves Staten Island customers seven days a week. Their Sicilian Pizza was chosen as the…
Italian Touch Pizza serves authentic Italian pizza, pastas, wings, and wraps using highest quality ingredients including high quality chicken, farm fresh veg…
Jimmy Max is an Italian restaurant and pizzeria established in 1989, located at 280 Watchogue Rd in Staten Island, NY. They serve pizza, pasta, and seafood, …
Joe & Pat's Pizzeria And Restaurant is located in Staten Island, New York. The restaurant has been operating since 1960 and claims to serve the best pizza on…
Visit website →
Kingdom Pizza is a pizza restaurant located at 4350 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10312. The menu features classic pies, specialty pies, lunch specials, rolls …
L&R Pizza & Pasta is a family-run pizzeria based in Staten Island, NY that offers L&R specials for pick up or delivery. They also provide catering services w…
Visit website →
La Bella Pizza SI is a family-owned neighborhood favorite in Staten Island that has proudly served the community for years. The restaurant specializes in aut…
La Piazza Pizza crafts each pizza with care using fresh ingredients including house-made sauces, perfectly melted cheeses, and premium toppings. The restaura…
La Vera Pizzeria is located at 2071 Clove Rd in Staten Island, NY. The restaurant offers various pizza styles including classic cheese pizza, Sicilian pizza,…
Lee's Tavern is a pizza and bar establishment located at 60 Hancock St. in Staten Island, NY. The site identifies it as the best pizza and bar in Staten Island.
Visit website →
A pizzeria located on Edgewater Street in Staten Island, Liberty Catering serves the waterfront community with pizza and catering options. Positioned along o…
Visit website →
Pizza lovers across Staten Island head to Little Caesars Pizza on Forest Avenue for convenient takeout and dine-in options. Located at 2040 Forest Ave, this …
Visit website →
Lorenzo's Pizza offers round pies, Sicilian pies, and pizza by the slice. House specialties include White Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, and Margherita Pizza.…
M & J Pizza operates from 10 Akron St in Staten Island, New York. The restaurant serves pizza to customers ordering for delivery, pickup, or dine-in service.…
Visit website →
Mamma Mia Pizzeria and Cucina serves pizza, pasta, salads, calzones and more using authentic Sicilian recipes brought from Sicily by owner Mario Badali's fat…
Visit website →
Mangia Pizzeria Ristorante is a warm neighborhood Italian restaurant in Staten Island that serves handcrafted pizzas, pasta, seafood, and classic Italian ent…
Metro Pizzeria & Restaurant is a family-owned pizzeria in Staten Island that has been operating since 2004. They serve oven-fresh pizza and Italian dishes ma…
Michaelangelo's Pizzeria is located at 860 Post Ave in Staten Island, NY and offers free delivery. The restaurant features house favorites including various …
Millie's Old World is an Italian restaurant located in Staten Island, New York. The site indicates they serve meatballs and pizza.
Mimmo's Brick Oven Pizza & Trattoria is a family-owned and operated Italian brick oven pizzeria and restaurant located in Great Kills, Staten Island, establi…
Mimmo's Pizza Shoppe is a pizza restaurant in Staten Island that has expanded to three locations, including a concession stand at TKR South Shore Babe Ruth. …
Mona Lisa Pizzeria is located in Annadale Town, Staten Island. The restaurant was voted "The Best Pizzeria" in North East America National Pizza Competition …
Visit website →
Mr Pizza's Pasta House serves pizza and pasta to Staten Island diners at 2325 Richmond Ave. The restaurant offers a casual dining environment suitable for lu…
Visit website →
My Family Pizza is located at 340 Victory Blvd in Staten Island, NY. The restaurant offers online ordering with 5% off and free delivery. They serve pizza, h…
Pizza R Us is a halal pizza restaurant in Staten Island that serves handcrafted specialty pies, fresh pasta, and wings cooked to order. All meat on the menu …
Napoli Pizza operates two locations in Staten Island and serves authentic New York-style pizza. They offer delivery, pick-up, and eat-in service, and provide…
Napoli Pizza operates two locations in Staten Island serving authentic New York-style pizza. They offer delivery, pick-up, and eat-in service, and provide at…
Nonna's Pizza SI operates two locations in Staten Island: one in Great Kills at 27 Brower Court and one in Tottenville at 311 Page Avenue. Both locations off…
Visit website →
Nonna's Pizza SI operates two locations in Staten Island: one in Great Kills at 27 Brower Ct and one in Tottenville at 311 Page Avenue. Both locations serve …
Visit website →
Located on Castleton Avenue in Staten Island, Oaxaca Pizzeria Deli & Taqueria brings together pizza, deli sandwiches, and tacos under one roof. The restauran…
Visit website →
Giuseppe's Pizza has been in business for over 25 years providing the neighborhood with delicious pizza and traditional Italian cuisine. They specialize in a…
Osteria by Primo is an Italian restaurant offering authentic Italian cuisine with dishes made from fine imported pastas and cheeses, locally sustainable fish…
Visit website →
Located on Page Avenue in Staten Island, Palermo Pizza serves the neighborhood with straightforward pizza made fresh. The spot works well for grabbing a quic…
Visit website →
Panini Grill is an authentic Italian family trattoria located in West Brighton, Staten Island, founded by two brothers from Italy. The restaurant offers home…
Papa Johns Pizza in Staten Island offers pizza delivery and carryout from their location at 1190 Forest Avenue. They serve pizza along with breadsticks and w…
Parma Pizzeria & Restaurant offers a fusion dining experience blending American flavors with fresh seafood, savory steaks, and vegetarian options. The menu i…
Patrizia's is a family-owned pizzeria in Staten Island that serves pizza and authentic Italian cuisine. The restaurant uses finest ingredients imported direc…
Patrizia's Taverna is located at 2636 Hylan Boulevard in Staten Island, serving pizza to the neighborhood. The restaurant operates as a casual dining spot wh…
Visit website →
Patrizia's of Staten Island offers Italian cuisine including pizzas, pastas, seafood, and meat entrees. The restaurant features family-style packages, appeti…
Piattino serves great Italian fare with a modern twist, sourcing artisan ingredients from around the world and locally. The restaurant features a stone-fired…
Visit website →
Piccolo Pinos Pizzeria is a pizzeria located at 275 Port Richmond Ave in Staten Island, NY. The restaurant offers various pizza styles including specialty pi…
Pienza Brick Oven Pizza Café is a social enterprise eatery owned by Lois & Richard Nicotra that gives 100% of its profits to scholarships and grants for loca…
Pier 76 is located near the Staten Island Ferry and St. George Theatre on Staten Island's North Shore. The restaurant serves authentic Italian dishes, artisa…
Visit website →
Pizza Mia operates on Richmond Road in Staten Island, serving pizza to the surrounding community. The restaurant is situated in a retail space on a major tho…
Visit website →
Located on Huguenot Avenue in Staten Island, Pizza Mia serves the local community with pizza and dining options. The restaurant sits in an accessible spot th…
Visit website →
Pizza Mia is a pizzeria located at 529 Tompkins Ave. in Staten Island, New York. The restaurant sits on Tompkins Avenue in a residential neighborhood accessi…
Visit website →
Pizza Mia Eltingville serves pizza to Staten Island residents and visitors on Richmond Avenue. The restaurant, formerly known as Dough, operates from its Elt…
Visit website →
Pizzaioli is located in the Great Kills neighborhood of Staten Island at 694 Arthur Kill Road. They serve pizza and Italian foods prepared fresh daily using …
Visit website →
Pizzeria Giove is a pizza restaurant located at 278 New Dorp Ln in Staten Island, NY. The menu features Classic Italian Pizzas, Red Specialty Pizzas, and Whi…
Plaza Pizza offers a variety of pizza styles including classic cheese pizza, Sicilian thick crust pan pizza, thin crust Sottile pizza, and specialty pizzas w…
Prime Pizza Kitchen is a pizzeria located on Hylan Boulevard in Staten Island, serving the neighborhood from its storefront at 1778 Hylan Blvd. The restauran…
Visit website →
Primo Pizzeria is a pizza restaurant in Staten Island that uses premium ingredients and offers generous portions. They offer pizza and specialty pizzas, and …
Located on Richmond Avenue in Staten Island, Pronto Pizza Pasta serves the local community with pizza and pasta options. The restaurant operates from its sto…
Visit website →
Located on Veterans Road West in Staten Island, Pronto Pizza Pasta serves the neighborhood with Italian-inspired dining. The restaurant welcomes diners seeki…
Visit website →
Pronto Pizza Pasta operates at 738 Forest Ave in Staten Island, serving pizza and pasta to the neighborhood. The restaurant is situated on Forest Avenue, a s…
Visit website →
Pronto Pizza Pasta operates at 337 New Dorp Ln in Staten Island's New Dorp neighborhood. The restaurant serves pizza and pasta to locals and visitors in the …
Visit website →
In Staten Island, Pronto Pizza Pasta serves pizza and pasta at 1077 Bay St, a location accessible to residents and visitors across the neighborhood. Whether …
Visit website →
Located on Hylan Boulevard in Staten Island, Rab's Country Lanes serves pizza to the local community. The restaurant sits in an accessible neighborhood locat…
Visit website →
Ralph's Sports Bar serves pizza at 1571 Richmond Rd in Staten Island. The restaurant operates as a casual dining spot on a well-traveled commercial stretch. …
Visit website →
Rosebank Pizza offers a variety of pizza styles including specialty pizzas, pan pizzas, Sicilian pizzas, and gluten-free options. The menu features house fav…
Rossville Best Pizza & Pasta is located at 55 Gunton Place in Staten Island and offers wood-fired pizzas, pasta dishes, and Italian cuisine. They provide fre…
Rossville Pizza is located at 960 Bloomingdale Rd in Staten Island, NY. The restaurant offers a menu featuring pizzas, appetizers, salads, and pasta dishes, …
Round Pie Pizza Company sits on Hylan Boulevard in Staten Island, serving up fresh pizza to the neighborhood. Located at 1919 Hylan Blvd, this pizzeria draws…
Visit website →
Located on Victory Boulevard in Staten Island, Round Pie Pizza Company serves the neighborhood with fresh pizza made to order. The restaurant welcomes diners…
Visit website →
Royal Pizza operates 2 locations in Staten Island, NY. Both locations offer free delivery with no minimum order requirement and estimated delivery times of 1…
Visit website →
Rustic Pizza & Pasteria in Staten Island offers handcrafted dishes and house-made pasta with weekly specials. They provide dine-in, take out, delivery, and c…
Sal & Lloyd's Pizza Place is located at 3850 Richmond Ave in Staten Island, NY. The restaurant offers a menu featuring various pizza styles including round c…
Diners and pizza lovers across Staten Island know San Marino Oriental Restaurant as a reliable stop on Hylan Boulevard. Located at 1465 Hylan Blvd, this esta…
Visit website →
Seppe Staten Island is a modern, family-friendly neighborhood pizzeria with comfortable, classic touches and a welcoming, laid-back atmosphere. They provide …
Visit website →
Square of Dongan Hills is a pizzeria in the Dongan Hills section of Staten Island that specializes in an upside down square pie. Established in 2025, they co…
Sunset Pizza offers a wide variety of pizza styles including classic round pies, pan pizzas, Sicilian and Grandma pizzas, and specialty options with unique t…
The Pizza Parlor is a modern take on the classic New York style pizzeria in Staten Island, NY. They blend timeless Italian American favorites with creative d…
Located on Jewett Avenue in Staten Island, The Pizza Parlor serves the local community with pizza prepared on-site. The restaurant's straightforward approach…
Visit website →
The Square On Annadale Pizzeria & Restaurant is located in Staten Island's Eltingville, Annadale neighborhood at 833 Annadale Road. The restaurant serves Ita…
Tommy's Tavern + Tap is a family-owned business located at 2655 Richmond Avenue in Staten Island, New York. The establishment serves food and drinks with ext…
Visit website →
Tony's Best Pizza and Pasta is located in Staten Island's Arden Heights neighborhood and serves pizzeria cuisine. The restaurant features a homemade sauce an…
Tony's Brick Oven Pizza opened in 1997 and practices old school Italian recipes and style to create authentic pizza and Italian cuisine. Originally from Mola…
Visit website →
Torino Pizza Cafe offers a variety of pizza styles including Sicilian, Grandma, Pan Pizza (Deep Dish), and traditional pizzas. The menu features house favori…
Towne Deli & Pizzeria is located at 5373 Arthur Kill Road in Tottenville, Staten Island, NY. Since 1971, it has been providing classic pizzeria cuisine along…
Tutto Apposto Cucina Italiana is an Italian restaurant in Richmond Valley, Staten Island. The restaurant features homemade pasta tossed in a wheel of Parmigi…
Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe is an Italian restaurant located at 1298 Forest Avenue in Staten Island, NY. They are the home of "The Four Corners" coal oven t…
Valducci's Pizza in Tottenville offers a variety of pizza styles including round Neapolitan pizzas, square Sicilian-style pizzas, and specialty options. The …
Valducci's Pizza has been making award-winning pizzas since 1989 and has been named "BEST Pizza" 5 times by the NY Daily News. They offer catering services i…
Verde's Pizza & Pasta House is located at 2220B Forest Ave in Staten Island, New York. This establishment serves pizza and pasta to diners in the Forest Aven…
Visit website →
Vesuvio's Trattoria & Pizzeria is located at 7423 Amboy Rd in Staten Island, NY. The restaurant offers pizza with gluten free and vegan options available, al…
Via Ponte Pizzeria has been serving Staten Island since 2002. They serve mouthwatering, tasteful pizza and pasta dishes and strive to provide great tasting a…
Villa Monte South is a pizzeria and restaurant in Tottenville, Staten Island that has been celebrating 40 years of Staten Island tradition. They serve authen…
Visit website →
Village Maria Pizza serves fresh pizza, classic Italian dishes, and specialty slices in a casual and family-friendly atmosphere. They use fresh ingredients a…
Village Maria Pizzeria is a pizzeria located at 3995 Amboy Rd (corner of Nelson Ave) in Staten Island, New York. The restaurant offers pizza, rolls, appetize…
Visit website →
In Staten Island, Wonder West Brighton serves pizza to the Forest Avenue neighborhood and surrounding communities. Located at 800 Forest Ave, this pizzeria d…
Visit website →
Zzs pizza and bar operates at Staten Island ferry terminal, located at 10 Ferry Terminal Viaduct. The restaurant sits in a transit hub where commuters and vi…
Visit website →
O Sfizio Ristorante is located at 4651 Hylan Boulevard in Staten Island, serving pizza to the neighborhood. The restaurant operates as a sit-down establishme…
Visit website →