Best Coal-Fired in New York

Coal ovens run hotter and char harder than gas or wood, giving these pies their signature leopard-spotted crust. These spots do it right.

Maine New Hampshire Massachusetts Rhode Island Connecticut Vermont New York New Jersey Pennsylvania

22 spots in New York

Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Angelo's Pizza

Angelo's Pizza

New York, NY

New York Style

Angelo's Pizza is a classic New York-style pizzeria located on Broadway serving authentic Italian pizza. Known for their traditional coal-fired brick oven pi…

Classic New York-style pizzacoal-fired brick oven pizzasItalian specialties
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Carle Place, NY

Coal-Fired

Anthony's fires every pizza in a 900-degree coal oven, creating a light, crisp crust. The menu features hand-made dough, vine-ripened tomato sauce, premium t…

Coal-fired Meatball & Ricotta pizzajumbo oven-roasted wingsfresh salads
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Commack, NY

Coal-Fired

Anthony's fires every pizza in a 900-degree coal oven, creating a crisp, lightly charred crust with premium toppings and house-made sauce. The menu includes …

Coal-fired pizzasoven-roasted wingsfresh salads
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Avicolli's Coal Fire

Avicolli's Coal Fire

Fayetteville, NY

Coal-Fired

Avicolli's Coal Fire is located in Fayetteville, NY and serves fresh coal fired pizza as well as gourmet Italian dishes. They also serve craft cocktails, bee…

Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Da Nico

Da Nico

New York, NY

Coal-Fired

Da Nico Ristorante has operated in Little Italy, New York since 1993, serving authentic Italian cuisine including handmade pasta and brick oven pizza. The re…

Handmade pastabrick oven pizzaGrilled Sausage Ring
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Don Giovanni

Don Giovanni

New York, NY

Coal-Fired

Don Giovanni has been serving Italian cuisine in Chelsea and the Theater District for almost a quarter of a century. Pizzas are their specialty, baked in an …

traditional Margherita PizzaQuattro FormaggiPizza Pomodori
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Brooklyn, NY

New York Style

Grimaldi's Pizzeria is a New York-style pizzeria located in the DUMBO neighborhood of Brooklyn, famous for its coal-fired brick oven pizza. The restaurant is…

Coal-fired brick oven pizzaclassic Margheritafresh mozzarella
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for John's of Bleecker Street

John's of Bleecker Street

New York, NY

New York Style

John's of Bleecker Street is a New York-style pizza institution operating in Greenwich Village. Known for their classic coal-fired brick oven pizzas and cris…

Coal-fired brick oven pizzaclassic New York-style slicescheese pizza
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Juliana's

Juliana's

Brooklyn, NY

New York Style

Juliana's is Patsy Grimaldi's return to 19 Old Fulton Street in DUMBO, the address under the Brooklyn Bridge where he first built his reputation. He opened i…

Sicilian pizzagrandma-style pizzasquare pizza with crispy crust
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Lombardi's

Lombardi's

New York, NY

New York Style

Lombardi's is America's first pizzeria, famous for authentic New York-style pizza. Known for their coal-fired brick oven and traditional thin-crust pizza wit…

Coal-fired thin-crust pizzaclassic cheese pizzatraditional Italian toppings
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Milkflower

Milkflower

Astoria, NY

Coal-Fired

Milkflower is a modern pizzeria in Astoria specializing in coal-fired Neapolitan-style pizza with high-quality ingredients. The restaurant offers a casual di…

Coal-fired Neapolitan pizzawood-fired preparationsspecialty pies with seasonal ingredients
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for PIZZA NOTA

PIZZA NOTA

Rochester, NY

Coal-Fired

Pizza Nota serves thin crust pies baked hot and fast in a coal-fired oven, inspired by New Haven's iconic char with a touch of New York influence. The menu f…

New Haven Tomato PieCup & CharEnzo
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Patsy's Pizzeria

Patsy's Pizzeria

New York, NY

Coal-Fired

Patsy's Pizzeria is located in East Harlem at 2287 1st Ave and features coal-fired ovens that craft thin, crispy crusts. The restaurant offers dine-in servic…

Patsy's Pizzeria Special (fresh mozzarellapepperonibasil
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Patsy's Pizzeria

Patsy's Pizzeria

New York, NY

New York Style

Patsy's Pizzeria traces its origin over a century to Manhattan's Lower East Side, with the first shop opening in Harlem in 1933. The restaurant is known for …

Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Patsy's Pizzeria - Whitestone

Patsy's Pizzeria - Whitestone

Queens, NY

Coal-Fired

Patsy's Pizzeria in Whitestone is a pizzeria restaurant with a bar lounge and private event rooms that offers signature New York flavors including classic co…

Classic coal-oven pizzashomemade pastasItalian classics
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Prince Street Pizza

Prince Street Pizza

Brooklyn, NY

New York Style

Prince Street Pizza is a New York-style pizza slice shop located in the heart of Brooklyn. Known for their classic coal-fired oven pizzas and dollar slices, …

Dollar slicespepperoni pizzaSicilian slice
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Sac's Place

Sac's Place

Astoria, NY

Coal-Fired

Sac's Place is a family-owned Italian restaurant in Astoria that has been operating since 1989, starting as a small pizzeria and expanding to a full-service …

Homemade pastacoal-brick oven pizza made with homemade doughgnocchi
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Salvatore's

Salvatore's

Port Washington, NY

Coal-Fired

Salvatore's Coal Oven Pizzeria was established in 1996 and serves authentic coal fired, brick oven pizza using fresh ingredients. The restaurant's roots trac…

Margherita PizzaWhite PizzaClam Pie with Casino Butter
Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Table 87

Table 87

Brooklyn, NY

Coal-Fired

Table 87 is a pizza restaurant in Brooklyn that has been operating since 2012, serving pizza the Brooklyn way. They offer pizza by the slice, full pies, and …

Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Table 87

Table 87

Brooklyn, NY

Coal-Fired

Table 87 is a pizza restaurant in Brooklyn that has been operating since 2012, offering pizza by the slice and full pies. They also serve cocktails and ship …

Visit website →
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe

Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe

Staten Island, NY

Coal-Fired

Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe is an Italian restaurant located at 1298 Forest Avenue in Staten Island, NY. They are the home of "The Four Corners" coal oven t…

The Four Corners coal oven thin crust pizza
Visit website →