Papa Gino's in Whitman has operated from 674 Bedford Street for over 60 years, drawing on an Italian family recipe that founder Mike Valerio brought from Italy in the 1930s. The pizzeria makes handmade pies with fresh ingredients, and the menu extends well beyond pizza to include hot appetizers like breadsticks and chicken tenders, pastas, subs, salads, and baskets. Ben & Jerry's ice cream rounds out the offerings. Delivery, dine-in, and in-store pickup are all available, and the location handles catering orders.