Middletown is home to 27 pizza restaurants featured in the Northeast Pizza Guide, spanning styles including Neapolitan, New York Style, Sicilian / Grandma, Thin Crust. Browse the full list below to explore what Middletown, New York has to offer.
All Pizza Restaurants in Middletown
3 Brothers Pizza is located at 1291 Dolsontown Rd in Middletown, NY. The menu features multiple pizza styles including Neapolitan, Sicilian, and specialty pi…
Adams Pizza Shop in Middletown serves fresh, made-to-order pizza from classic pies to distinctive specialty pizzas, available for quick pickup. The menu incl…
Alfonso's is located at 835 NY-211 in Middletown, New York. This pizzeria serves the area along this well-traveled route, offering dine-in and takeout option…
Visit website →
Badabing Pizzeria is located at 28 County Rd 78 in Middletown, NY. The restaurant offers a wide variety of pizzas including specialty options, sicilian pizza…
Pizza lovers in Middletown will find Bella Lena's at 511 NY-17M, a welcoming spot for satisfying cravings any day of the week. Whether you're dining in or or…
Visit website →
Located in Middletown, New York, Brother Bruno's Pizzeria serves pizza to locals and visitors along Dolson Avenue. The restaurant welcomes diners seeking a c…
Visit website →
Caputo's Pizza is located at 36 James St in Middletown, New York. The restaurant specializes in pizza, serving the local community with made-to-order pies av…
Visit website →
Carlos Pizza and Bar in Middletown offers classic Italian tradition with specialty pizzas, hearty pastas, and a cozy dine-in experience. The restaurant featu…
Colandrea Pizza King is a family-run pizzeria in Middletown that has served the community for decades with authentic Italian dishes and inventive pizzas. The…
Visit website →
Cosimo's Brick Oven is a restaurant that has worked with Hudson Valley family farms for over 35 years, offering handcrafted mozzarella, sauces, desserts, and…
Cuginos is a family-owned and operated pizzeria that focuses on using real ingredients and honoring classic Italian-American recipes. They handcraft pizzas w…
Middletown's Franco Di Roma serves pizza at 357 NY-211, offering a straightforward dining and ordering experience in the area. The restaurant welcomes custom…
Visit website →
Frank's Pizza & Italian Restaurant has served the Middletown community for over 20 years with high-quality Italian dishes and specialty pizzas in a cozy, fam…
Joey's Pizza in Middletown serves pizza and Italian cuisine including pasta, available for lunch or dinner with dine-in, take-out, and delivery options. Spec…
John's of Arthur Ave is a pizza restaurant in Middletown, NY located at 19 W Main St. They offer Arthur Ave. Style Pizza with thin & crispy crust, zesty sauc…
Located on Wickham Avenue in Middletown, Little Caesars Pizza serves the local community with convenient pizza ordering and takeout options. The restaurant s…
Visit website →
Monroy's Pizza in Middletown, NY serves delicious pizza, subs, salads and pasta. They offer a Jumbo Slice Experience and provide delivery and catering services.
One Way Cafe & Pizza is located at 11 Mulberry St in Middletown, NY. The restaurant offers a pizza menu with varieties including plain pizza, white pizza, sp…
Visit website →
Family pizzeria in Middletown, New York located on Tower Drive offering hand-tossed NY-style pizza, fresh mozzarella specials, wings, pasta, burgers, and mor…
Pellegrino & Son's Pizzeria is located at 65 Dolson Ave in Middletown, NY. The restaurant offers lunch dinners available from 11:00 AM - 3:00 PM, including p…
Visit website →
Pizza E Birra serves pizza and beer in Middletown on NY-211, a convenient location for dining in or ordering takeout. The restaurant combines Italian pizza t…
Visit website →
Pizza Hut at 280 Route 211 East in Middletown, NY serves pizza, wings, pastas and desserts. They offer delivery and carryout options with online ordering ava…
Pizza Star is a family Italian restaurant located on Route 211 in Middletown, NY, serving old fashioned tomato pie, specialty pizzas, pasta, and Italian favo…
Sicilian Delight is a pizza restaurant located at 1 N Galleria Dr in Middletown, NY. The restaurant offers a variety of pizzas including specialty options, g…
Soprano's Pizzeria in Middletown, NY offers pizza, appetizers, soups, and salads. The menu includes plain cheese pizza, specialty pizzas with various topping…
Visit website →
Villa Gaudio of Bullville Inc is a pizzeria located at 2856 NY-17K in Middletown, New York. Situated along this major route through Orange County, the restau…
Visit website →
Yovanis Pizzeria operates at 741 NY-211 in Middletown, New York. Located on this main route through town, the pizzeria serves pizza to customers seeking take…
Visit website →