Thick-crusted and cut into squares — a diner and pizzeria staple across the Northeast. These spots do it well.
81 spots in New Jersey
Adoro Pizza & Pasta offers pizza, pasta, and other Italian dishes. The menu includes house favorites such as Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza…
Alba Pizza offers a variety of pizza styles including Sicilian cheese pizza with thick crust square format, pan pizza cooked in olive oil-coated pan, and gou…
Ameti's Pizza Restaurant in Pequannock Township, NJ offers pizza, square pizzas, pasta, sandwiches, wraps, and paninis. The restaurant features house favorit…
Angelo's II Pizzeria & Restaurant is located at 435 Amwell Rd in Hillsborough, NJ. The restaurant offers a variety of pizzas including specialty options like…
Anthony's Pizza in Sewell, NJ offers pizza and Italian cuisine available for pickup and delivery. They are known for their Grandma Pizza, which features a th…
Antonio's Old World Pizza is located at 10 Willow Rd in Maple Shade, NJ. The restaurant offers a variety of pizzas including specialty options like Sicilian,…
Attilio's of Wall offers pizza in various styles including traditional, Sicilian, Grandma, pan, and gluten-free options. The menu features house favorites su…
Barclay Pies is a neighborhood pizzeria in Cherry Hill, NJ that makes all sauces, dough, hand-breaded mozzarella sticks, and tenders from scratch. They offer…
Basilico Pizza is a pizza restaurant located at 3815 Church Rd in Mount Laurel Township, NJ. The menu features fresh dough made daily and offers a variety of…
Bella Mia Pizzeria in Phillipsburg, NJ offers a wide variety of pizza options including classic cheese pizza, gourmet pizzas, thick crust pan pizzas, square …
Visit website →
Benny Tudino's is a pizza institution in Hoboken known for its square Sicilian-style pizza and generous portions. The restaurant has been serving thick, cris…
Brooklyn Original Pizzeria serves Brooklyn style square pies and traditional pizzas. All pizzas are made with thin, crispy crust and are well done but never …
Brooklyn Pizza offers pizzas, appetizers, salads, and Italian entrees. The menu includes house favorites like Bruschetta Pizza and Drunken Grandma Pizza, alo…
Brooklyn Square Pizza is a family-owned local pizzeria with locations across New Jersey. They offer traditional Italian pizza made with fresh ingredients and…
Brooklyn Square Pizza is a family-owned local pizzeria offering traditional Italian pizza made with fresh ingredients and classic recipes. They serve upside-…
Brooklyn Square Pizza is a family-owned local pizzeria offering traditional Italian pizza made with fresh ingredients and classic recipes. They serve upside-…
Brooklyn Square Pizza is a family-owned local pizzeria offering traditional Italian pizza made with fresh ingredients and classic recipes. They serve a menu …
Capone's Gourmet Pizza & Pasta is a family-owned wood-fired pizzeria in Toms River, NJ offering fresh homemade Italian food. Their menu includes gourmet pizz…
Parkside Pizza - Casa Turano offers a variety of pizzas including Sicilian pizza with thick crust, Grandma square pan-cooked pizza, and specialty options lik…
A family-owned restaurant in downtown Westfield offering traditional, rustic Italian cuisine including pizza, focaccia sandwiches, paninis, subs, and fresh p…
Corner Slice is a neighborhood slice shop that relocated to Maplewood, New Jersey after 7 years in New York City. Their "New York Square Pie" was named one o…
Crust N Fire has served the South Jersey community since 2018 with handcrafted pizza and Italian favorites made with quality ingredients. They offer multiple…
Crust N Fire has served the South Jersey community since 2018 with fresh, handcrafted pizza and Italian favorites made with quality ingredients. They offer h…
Crust N Fire has served the South Jersey community for over 30 years with fresh, handcrafted pizza and Italian favorites. The restaurant offers handcrafted p…
D' Carlo Pizzeria is located at 111 Lawrenceville Rd in Lawrence Township, NJ. The menu features various pizza styles including Sicilian thick crust, Brookly…
Danny's Pizza Pizzazz in Vineland, NJ offers pizza, wings, cheesesteaks, hoagies, and pasta dishes. The restaurant features daily specials throughout the wee…
DiMola's Pizza offers a variety of pizza styles including classic cheese pizza, gourmet pizzas, and specialty options like Sicilian and Pan pizzas. The menu …
Dominick's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria is the first and oldest pizza restaurant in Newton, NJ, family owned and operated since the 1960s. The owners lear…
Dominick's Pizza offers a variety of pizza styles including traditional cheese pizza, Sicilian pizza, gluten-free pizza, and specialty pizzas. The menu also …
East Ridge Pizzeria is a pizza restaurant located at 621 Beverly Rancocas Rd in Willingboro, NJ. The menu features various pizza styles including Sicilian pi…
Emilia Romagna Pizza & Ristorante is located at 247 Valley Blvd in Wood-Ridge, NJ. The restaurant offers pizza in multiple styles including Sicilian, New Yor…
Fabiano's Pizza offers a variety of pizza styles including specialty pizzas, square pizzas, and slices. The menu features house favorites like Margherita Piz…
Fabio's Bistro is a pizzeria in Fanwood, NJ located at 217 South Ave. The restaurant offers New York Style pizza, Sicilian Style pizza, Brooklyn Square pizza…
Francesco's Italian Pizzeria & Restaurant in Phillipsburg, NJ offers a wide variety of pizzas with both classic and specialty options, along with Italian ent…
Frank's Pizza in Hackettstown, NJ offers a wide variety of pizza styles including round pies, square crust options, thick crust pan pizzas, and Sicilian pizz…
Frank's Pizza & Italian Restaurant in East Brunswick, NJ offers a wide variety of pizzas including round, sicilian, and deep dish styles, along with appetize…
Frankie G's Pizza is a pizza restaurant located at 197 NJ-70 W in Toms River, NJ. The menu features various pizza styles including classic cheese pizza, pan …
Fratelli's Pizza & Pasta in Clifton, NJ offers pizza, pasta, and seafood dishes. The menu includes house favorites such as various pizza styles including Gra…
Giovanni Italian Style Pizza offers fresh dough made daily for their pizzas. They serve multiple pizza styles including regular, gourmet, Sicilian, and pan p…
Hopewell Sub & Pizza has been serving meals in Bridgeton, NJ since 1961. They offer a casual sub and pizzeria with fresh pizza, subs, wraps, and salads prepa…
Industry Squares is a restaurant in Edison, NJ formerly known as Deserios Trattoria. They serve pizza, rolls, sandwiches and more.
Visit website →
Italian Village Pizza is located at 300 Main St in Madison, New Jersey. The menu features various pizza styles including specialty pizzas, grandma pizzas, an…
Joe's Pizza in Bridgeton, NJ offers a menu featuring pizzas, sandwiches, salads, and appetizers. The restaurant highlights house favorites marked as "NEW" it…
Joey D's Pizza offers a variety of pizza styles including Cheese Pizza, Thin Crust Pizza, Sicilian Pizza, Grandma Pizza, Pan Cheese Pizza, and Gluten Free Ch…
Visit website →
Johnny's Pizzeria offers a variety of pizza styles including Sicilian, Grandma, and Gluten Free options, along with specialty pizzas, appetizers, soups, and …
Kosher Square Pizza specializes in handcrafted New York-style square pizzas featuring airy crusts, house-made sauces, fresh mozzarella, and authentic Italian…
La Rosa Pizzeria offers pizza in various styles including Sicilian, Brooklyn thin crust, and New Jersey style, along with appetizers and family deals. The me…
Lucia's Pizzeria offers pizza, appetizers, salads, and various entrees including tacos, quesadillas, and pasta. The menu features both classic and specialty …
Luigi's Square Pizza is home to their famous extra large 16 slice square pizza and many more delicious options. They offer takeout, delivery, catering, and c…
Mariana's Pizzeria & Latin Grill offers pizza, appetizers, and soups. The menu includes various pizza styles such as Sicilian, Deep Dish, and thin crust opti…
Marcello Pizza & Italian is located at 3112 Mount Ephraim Ave in Haddon Township, NJ. The restaurant offers pizza, salads, side orders, and deals. Online ord…
Massa Roman Square Pizza & Italian Specialties is located at 405 Park Ave in Scotch Plains, NJ. The restaurant offers Roman square pizza made with San Marzan…
Maurizio Pizzeria & Italian Ristorante is located at 613 Hope Rd in Eatontown, NJ. The restaurant offers pizzas, including Sicilian and gluten-free options, …
MiAngelo's is a pizzeria located at 833 3rd Ave in Phillipsburg, NJ that offers a wide variety of pizza styles including round pizzas, Sicilian pizzas, and t…
Mulberry Street Pizza offers a variety of pizza styles including specialty pizzas, pan pizzas, square crust pies, and gluten-free options. The menu features …
Mythos Pizzeria is located in Blueberry Crossings in Hammonton, NJ. They offer quality pizza, cheesesteaks, wings, gyros and more, with both take out and din…
Original Dominick's Pizzeria & Italian Grill is located at 206 Sanhican Dr in Trenton, NJ. The restaurant offers various pizza styles including round thin cr…
Pipolo's Pizza is a pizza restaurant located at 50 Bridge St in Milford, NJ. The menu features a variety of pizza styles including classic cheese pizza, spec…
Pizza Palace of Randolph offers a diverse menu including pizzas, calzones, stromboli, salads, subs, and dinner entrees. The restaurant features specialty piz…
Pizza RIA is a pizza restaurant located at 1900 NJ-70 in Manchester Township, NJ. The menu features various pizza styles including Sicilian, Grandma, and spe…
Pizzarama offers a wide variety of pizza styles including classic round pizzas, Sicilian pizzas, pan pizzas, Chicago style, and specialty square pizzas such …
Qua Pizza is built on simple, high-quality ingredients and thoughtful technique, celebrating flavor in its purest form. The menu features Roman square pizza,…
Roberto's Pizzeria & Restaurant in Teaneck, NJ offers pizzas, appetizers, salads, soups, and pasta dishes. The menu features both classic and gourmet pizza o…
Roberto's Pizza & Grill is located at 456 Joralemon St in Belleville, NJ. The menu features a wide variety of pizzas including specialty options like Penne V…
Romeo's Pizza offers a diverse menu including traditional pizzas, gourmet specialty pizzas, rolls, calzones, and Italian entrees. The restaurant features hou…
Rose's Pizza has been serving Garfield, New Jersey since 1976 using the same fresh ingredients from day one. Everything is made with love and care, with each…
SQ Pizza serves authentic Roman Style pizza made with imported non-GMO flour from Italy. Their dough uses a 72-hour high hydration fermentation process resul…
Santucci's is the home of Philadelphia's Original Square Pizza. Pizza is described as more than a meal—it's a tradition at Santucci's.
Visit website →
Santucci's is the home of Philadelphia's original square pizza. At Santucci's, pizza is more than a meal — it's a tradition. The restaurant has been recogniz…
Visit website →
Santucci's is the home of Philadelphia's original square pizza. Pizza is described as more than a meal—it's a tradition at Santucci's.
Visit website →
Santucci's is described as the home of Philadelphia's original square pizza. The restaurant offers pizza as a tradition and serves square slices to customers…
Visit website →
Sea Bright Pizzeria & Restaurant is a family owned and run pizzeria since 2006. The restaurant uses only San Marzano tomatoes, Grande mozzarella, and product…
Spinachio Pizza is located at 5 Sicomac Rd Ste 10 in North Haledon, NJ. The restaurant specializes in bar-style pizzas that are stretched thin and baked with…
Stella Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria in Cherry Hill, New Jersey, established in 2005. They serve authentic Italian pizza in New York style thin crust (squ…
TJ's Pizza offers a variety of pizzas including round cheese pizza, thin crust pizza, square Sicilian pizza, and specialty options like Buffalo Chicken, Gran…
The Original Primo Pizza offers a variety of pizzas including Brooklyn-style, Sicilian, and specialty options, along with wings, salads, calzones, and other …
Tiga's Artisan Pizzeria in Medford, New Jersey offers pizzas made with 100% organic flour, 100% organic tomatoes, and non-GMO & antibiotic-free mozzarella ch…
Tony's Pizza Pasta Grill is a restaurant located at 755 Van Houten Ave in Clifton, NJ that serves pizza, pasta, wings, and Italian dishes. The site highlight…
Tuscana's Pizzeria & Restaurant 2 in Hopatcong, NJ offers a variety of pizza styles including round pizzas, pan pizzas, Sicilian square pizzas, and flatbread…
Valentino's Pizza offers a variety of pizza styles including classic cheese pizza, Sicilian pizza, and gourmet options with specialty toppings. The menu feat…
Via Roma II is a pizza restaurant located at 1280 Yardville Allentown Rd in Allentown, NJ. The menu features various pizza styles including plain cheese, Sic…