🍕 Now building the Northeast's best pizza directory — Submit your favorite spot
Northeast Pizza Guide
The Regional Pizza Directory
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Cara Mia's

Cara Mia's

📍 Rutland, Vermont

Cara Mia's hand-spins fresh dough and bakes pizzas directly on hot bricks, topping them with their own original red tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella. Beyond their $18 large cheese pick-up special, the menu offers build-your-own options and specialty pies like the Clam Casino (with chopped clams, bacon, and spinach) and a Sicilian square pan that requires two hours' notice. The kitchen also turns out pasta dishes, subs, calzones, and Italian entrées like seven-layer lasagna and eggplant rollatini.

Known For

Pick-Up Special: Large Cheese Pizza $18.00; Pasta Special: Spaghetti or Rigatoni with Meatball or Sausage $10.00; Sicilian Square Pan Baked (Pre-Order Only – 2 Hours)
50 Strongs Ave, Rutland, VT 05701, USA

Location

Nearby Pizza

Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Ramunto's
New York Style
Ramunto's
📍 Rutland, Vermont · 0.2 mi
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Domino's Pizza
Domino's Pizza
📍 Rutland, Vermont · 0.4 mi
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Vermont Tap House
Wood-Fired
Vermont Tap House
📍 Rutland, Vermont · 0.4 mi
Representative Northeast Pizza Guide image for Ted's Pizza Shop
Ted's Pizza Shop
📍 Rutland, Vermont · 0.5 mi