Amore Pizza
Amore Pizza, founded January 1st, 1991, is a catering and delivery pizzeria that has served the community for more than 28 years. They offer daily menu items…
Cold PlattersHot Food TraysParty Hero pizzas
Visit website →
All Pizza Restaurants in Bay Shore
Bar Lucy - Italian Restaurant Bay Shore
Bar Lucy is a neighborhood Italian restaurant in Bay Shore offering hand-crafted, timeless dishes and expertly-made cocktails in a comfortable and intimate s…
Pastasteakchicken
Visit website →
Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza operates at 1701 Sunrise Highway in Bay Shore, New York. The restaurant serves pizza to customers in this Long Island location. Diners can visit …
Visit website →
Bono's Pizzeria
Bono's Pizzeria is located at 1397 Brentwood Rd in Bay Shore, NY. The restaurant offers pizza, appetizers, soups, salads, calzones, heroes, and pasta dishes.…
Bono's Special PizzaBono's Special Sicilian Pizzaand Grandma's Famous Soups
Visit website →
Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant is located at 1556 Brentwood Rd in Bay Shore, NY. The restaurant offers a menu featuring various pizza styles including classic…
House Favorites including Cheese PieCaesar Salad with Chicken PizzaAlfredo Chicken Pizza
Visit website →
Buseto Pizza
Buseto Pizza is a family-run pizzeria established in 1984 that serves traditional high-quality Italian cuisine and gourmet specialty pizza. The restaurant is…
Grilled Chicken Caesar SliceCapellini Pozzo Rocca
Visit website →
Domino's Pizza
Domino's Pizza offers pizza delivery and carryout along with pasta, wings, and more. The menu includes specialty pizzas, breads, chicken, desserts, oven-bake…
Specialty PizzasOven-Baked PastasOven-Baked Sandwiches
Visit website →
Fratelli Pizzeria
Fratelli Ristorante & Pizzeria is a family-owned and operated pizzeria located in Bay Shore, New York, serving since 1977. They offer dine-in service, delive…
Visit website →
Le Pizza
Pizza lovers around Bay Shore will find Le Pizza at 60 Bay Walk, a welcoming spot for casual dining and takeout in the neighborhood. Whether you're a local s…
Visit website →
Mama Mia's Pizza Of Bay Shore
Mama Mia's Bayshore is a pizzeria and restaurant in Bay Shore, New York that serves authentic Italian dining. They use premium imported Italian flour, Stanis…
Garlic knot pieSicilian cornerwhite slice
Visit website →
Mulberry Street Bay Shore
Mulberry Street Restaurant was established in 1976 and has been setting the standard for Italian cuisine and pizza in the Bay Shore community. They offer piz…
Visit website →
Nopal Pizzeria
Bay Shore's Nopal Pizzeria serves pizza at 1806 5th Ave, making it accessible to locals and visitors exploring the neighborhood. Whether you're ordering ahea…
Visit website →
Sbarro
Sbarro at Bay Shore offers handmade pizza made fresh with hand-stretched dough, San Marzano style sauce, and 100% whole milk mozzarella. The restaurant serve…
handmade pizza with hand-stretched doughfamous strombolibreadsticks
Visit website →
The Pie at Salvatore's
The Pie at Salvatores is a family-run pizzeria operating since 1933, located in Bay Shore, New York. They offer dine-in, take-out, and DoorDash delivery serv…
Visit website →
The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
The Pizzeria is a pizzeria restaurant with multiple locations across Long Island, New York. They offer dine-in service, online ordering, and catering service…
Visit website →
Valentino’s Peruvian Restaurant
Valentino's Pizza offers pizza, pasta specialties, salads, chicken dishes, and Italian heroes. Pasta dishes can be prepared with spaghetti, penne, fettuccine…
Large Pie (16 inch)Sicilian PieGrandma Pie
Visit website →
Victorio II Pizza
Pizza lovers in Bay Shore will find Victorio II Pizza at 20 Bay Shore Road, ready to serve up satisfying slices and whole pies. Whether you're stopping in af…
Visit website →
Victorio's Pizza
Victorio's Pizza is a pizzeria located at 1205 Sunrise Highway in Bay Shore, New York. Situated along this major thoroughfare, the restaurant serves the Bay …
Visit website →
Villa Roma Pizzeria & Restaurant
Villa Roma Pizzeria & Restaurant is located at 73 Howells Road, Bay Shore, NY 11706. They serve Italian cuisine and offer delivery to Bay Shore, Brightwaters…
Visit website →
Zest
Zest is described as the best American restaurant in Bay Shore, NY. The restaurant offers a casual, family-friendly atmosphere suitable for creative date nig…
NachosCrispy Smoked WingsCauliflower Crust Chips
Visit website →