New Fancy House of Pizza sits on Main Street in South Grafton and operates as a family-owned pizzeria focused on oven-hot pies alongside a broader menu. Beyond pizza, they offer subs, fresh salads, and a pasta selection that includes Alfredo with chicken, spaghetti, ziti with meat sauce and meatball, penne marinara, and ravioli marinara—each pasta dish comes with salad and garlic bread. Their dinner menu is designed for feeding groups, and they emphasize using fresh ingredients and preparing food to order.