Representative image
Mr. Pizza operates out of a small Beach Street location in Westerly, serving 14-inch pies built around two distinct styles: red pizzas made with crushed tomato sauce, and white pizzas without sauce. The menu spans familiar territory—Margherita, Pepperoni—but leans toward more considered combinations like the Toscano, a bar-style flat and crispy pie finished with sauce on top and seasoned with oregano and red chili flakes, or the Sausage Combo, which pairs house-made meatballs with roasted peppers and sautéed onions. Signature options include the Gar-Leek, built on a mozzarella base with garlic confit and buttery leeks, and the Apple Pie, a white pizza topped with cheddar, tart apples, bacon, and fresh mozzarella, served with hot honey for drizzling. Beyond pizza, they offer house-cut fries, garlic focaccia bread with house-made marinara, and salads including a chop salad with house-made balsamic vinaigrette. The operation runs Thursday through Sunday with limited hours and encourages preorders, as they tend to sell out during busy periods.