Representative image
Brewster Pizza House & Sports Bar sits on Main Street in Brewster with a straightforward approach: pizza in a range of styles, from white pies with feta and mozzarella to meat-heavy combinations, alongside a supporting menu of calzones, wings, salads, and burgers. The specialty pizzas skip traditional red sauce on several offerings—the Angus Burger Pizza, Steak Pizza, and Steak Bomb all come without it—while others swap in BBQ or buffalo bases. You can build your own pie or order from their house favorites, which include a basic cheese pizza and an Angus burger alongside sides like garden salad and antipasto.