Antonio's has operated as a slice shop on North Pleasant Street since 1991, serving the college town with both traditional and creative pizzas. The counter-service operation turns out Sicilian and thin-crust slices throughout the day—Cheese, Pepperoni, Mushroom, and Sausage among the regular offerings—alongside specials that rotate through the oven. On Wednesdays, all slices drop to $3. The place handles orders standing at the counter, at tables, or for takeout and delivery, and has developed enough staying power that alumni return to verify their slice tastes the way they remember it. Late hours on weekends (open until 1 AM Friday and Saturday) make it a destination for evening crowds.